5 Points : Singapore’s Property Market vs. Stock Market: Which is the Better Investment Option?
Investing is an important aspect of personal finance and can be a valuable way to grow wealth over time. However,...
Read More
TLDR
Recent challenges in China’s real estate sector reveal valuable lessons for Singaporeans, emphasizing the importance of understanding governmental interventions in property markets. While China’s cultural preference for home ownership and speculative investments mirrors Singapore’s, policy changes in both countries highlight potential risks for homeowners. Singapore’s history of significant policy shifts, such as the Built-To-Order system and en-bloc sales facilitation, showcases the delicate balance between supply and demand. With rising property prices and government interventions, the real estate market remains complex, urging buyers and sellers to consider strategic decisions carefully. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for navigating Singapore’s real estate landscape effectively.
Recent challenges in China’s real estate sector have highlighted the ways in which governments can and do intervene in property markets. The Chinese government’s efforts to assist its ailing property industry have unfortunately come at the expense of investors and homeowners, with previous policies being abruptly overturned. Although such drastic measures are uncommon in Singapore, similar interventions have occurred, and property owners frequently neglect to consider these actions as potential risks.
What reasons should Singaporeans have for paying attention to China’s real estate market?
Beyond the most apparent reason—namely, that numerous prominent Chinese developers are actively engaged in projects in Singapore—there are significant parallels between the two markets.
In China, there exists a deep cultural preference for home ownership, which the government actively promotes over renting. Chinese property buyers tend to favor real estate over more abstract investments like stocks, often with a focus on potential resale profits. Conversations with Chinese investors, whether in their home country or in Singapore, reveal a common perception of real estate as a safety net: homeowners believe they can always sell and downsize if necessary. This mindset closely resembles that of Singaporeans regarding home ownership.
Furthermore, the actions of Chinese policymakers echo those familiar to Singaporeans. For instance, in Chengdu, a lottery system is implemented to allocate new flats, while some cities enforce a mandatory holding period of 3.5 years for property purchases. During periods of rapid growth in China’s real estate market, these measures were intended to curb speculation; however, following the collapse of major players like Evergrande and a decline in market confidence, most of these restrictions have now been lifted.
We frequently overlook the significant scale of the policy changes that have taken place in Singapore
A prominent example of this can be observed in post-independence Singapore, where significant efforts were made to provide housing for the majority of the population. To rapidly increase the housing supply, the government acquired land at prices that would alarm any real estate investor today. Prior to 2007, when land was compulsorily acquired, compensation was based on market prices from several years prior (for instance, acquisitions from 1987 were compensated according to prices from 1973). This approach was taken with little remorse, as it was deemed essential for the nation’s reconstruction following the war.
Conversely, the government has also implemented drastic measures during periods of oversupply. A notable example is the Built To Order (BTO) system, which arose after the Housing and Development Board (HDB) faced a significant supply excess beginning in 1989. Under the BTO system, construction would only commence once there was adequate interest expressed in a site, and this method proved effective for a time.
However, this illustrates the fragile nature of supply and demand dynamics: in the aftermath of COVID-19, HDB encountered a housing deficit, which we attribute to the same BTO system. Had HDB been allowed to construct more swiftly in anticipation of demand, without such restrictions, the housing shortage might have been resolved more quickly.
Nevertheless, this could ultimately serve as merely a temporary solution in the long term. We have previously discussed the potential for future oversupply, particularly given trends such as smaller household sizes, declining birth rates, and the passing of the older generation.
Another instance worth mentioning is our approach to en-bloc sales. Through discussions within the community, it has become clear that not many individuals are aware that it is the government that facilitated en-bloc sales.
The Land Titles (Strata) (Amendment) Bill 1999 enabled collective sales to proceed with just 80 percent consensus (based on share value and strata area). Without this government intervention, en-bloc sales would require unanimous approval, which is nearly unattainable except for very small boutique projects.
But why would the government engage in a private free-market process? The rationale lies in maintaining a balance of supply and demand: en-bloc sales ultimately enhance the available housing stock, as redevelopment is justified by improved land usage. This also helps rejuvenate the built environment and prevents urban decline.
Supply and demand dynamics also significantly affect individual home buyers.
Two recent instances illustrate how an increase in supply can influence buyer interest:
The first example is the Lentor area, which has remained relatively quiet for the past decade. Recently, however, five condominium projects have emerged here in just two years. While there was previously pent-up demand, potential buyers may now be questioning whether the balance has shifted too far in favor of supply.
Another example is the intense competition among Tembusu Grand, Grand Dunman, and The Continuum, all located in close proximity from Katong to the boundary of Paya Lebar. As discussed in this article, such competition typically affects sales dynamics.
This situation unfolds against the backdrop of rising government supply, with the inventory of unsold homes currently hovering around 20%. This figure may increase further by the end of 2024 due to a combination of high prices for new launches and additional project completions.
Despite this, many buyers still find the property prices in 2024 to be prohibitive, as new launches are averaging over $2,100 per square foot and resale condos are exceeding $1,600 per square foot. This leads to the complex question of whether it’s time to set limits: is supply adequate when prices remain so high?
Conversely, at what point does supply become “excessive” enough to cause a significant drop in home prices? This remains a matter of speculation with no straightforward answer.
It’s worth noting that HDB flats are also affected by this dynamic. As we’ve frequently mentioned, HDB flats are particularly susceptible to oversupply due to their inherent restrictions. For instance, foreigners are not permitted to purchase HDB flats, while permanent residents may face longer waiting times; additionally, Singaporeans are limited to owning only one HDB property. If the government were to overbuild, correcting the supply imbalance would be much more challenging compared to private homes, where foreigners or PRs can help absorb some of the demand.
Are there properties that can withstand oversupply?
Historically, a prevalent sales argument for prime location properties was their immunity to oversupply. The notion was that, regardless of how many condos are constructed in areas like Bedok, Orchard, or Upper Bukit Timah, the value of condos in places like Orchard would remain unaffected due to the unique nature of the property’s location.
While this theory seems plausible, data indicates that prime freehold properties often perform less favorably, though this is not necessarily tied to issues of supply or scarcity.
One of the primary motivations for owning a freehold landed property, such as a Good Class Bungalow (GCB), stems from the adage that “they don’t make them anymore.” It appears that perhaps only the wealthiest individuals, who can afford such properties, are insulated from the fluctuations of supply and demand and the ongoing policy adjustments designed to regulate them.
Preserving the Fragile Equilibrium
The relationship between supply and demand in the real estate market is a complex interaction that necessitates careful oversight. An excess of supply can result in a surplus, leading to reduced prices and potentially creating financial hardships for both homeowners and developers. On the other hand, insufficient supply can elevate prices to levels that are out of reach for many, thereby increasing inequality and excluding numerous individuals from the housing market.
In Singapore, the government has historically played a crucial role in maintaining this equilibrium. Initiatives like the Built-To-Order (BTO) system and modifications to en-bloc sales demonstrate a continuous effort to adjust supply according to demand. Yet, as recent events have illustrated, these interventions are not always perfectly timed or effectively implemented.
However, there’s an interesting paradox. While many desire lower property prices, this sentiment often shifts once they secure their own property, at which point they may find themselves wanting prices to rise.
Should You Buy, Sell or Wait?
If you’re reading this, you must be trying to figure out the best course of action right now: is it the right time to buy or sell?
It’s difficult to give an exact answer since everyone’s situation is unique and what works for one person may not necessarily work for you.
I can bring you a wealth of on-the-ground experience and a data-driven approach to provide clarity and direction. From beginners to experienced investors, our top-down, objective approach will help you on your real estate journey.
I can help you by:
- Offering Strategic Real Estate Advice – I can help create a comprehensive plan to guide you through your property journey.
- Connecting Your Home with the Perfect Buyers – Through stunning visuals, an effective communication strategy, and an in-depth knowledge of the market, we’ll ensure your home is presented in the best possible way to fulfill your goals.
You May Also Like …
Maximize Your Property Investment: 5 Questions to Ask Your Real Estate Agent in Singapore
Buying a property in Singapore can be a daunting task, especially for first-time buyers. It is important to have a...
Read More
Top 5 Reasons : Why Do Singaporeans Still Flood The Property Market?
Singapore's property market has been a hot topic of discussion for many years, with its resilience and growth attracting both...
Read More
Top 5 Rooftop Bars in Singapore with Amazing Views
Top 5 Rooftop Bars in Singapore with Amazing Views Singapore, the Lion City, is known for its stunning skyline and...
Read More
Property Unpacked: Is GLS Impacting Property Values?
TLDR The Government Land Sales (GLS) program in Singapore is critical for developers to obtain development land, with sites released...
Read More
Beyond Marina Bay Sands: Uncovering Singapore’s 5 Little-Known Secrets
Beyond Marina Bay Sands: Uncovering Singapore's 5 Little-Known Secrets Singapore is a small country with a rich history and culture....
Read More
Top 5 Parks and Nature Reserves to Visit in Singapore
Singapore, often referred to as the "Garden City," is a vibrant and diverse nation that has made significant strides in...
Read More
Finding Your Dream Home In The Near Future. Exciting Upcoming Property Launches In The First Half Of 2024
TLDR The real estate sector in 2023 saw significant policy shifts affecting both private and public housing, with various changes...
Read More
Top 5 Factors : Buying Resale vs New Launch Property in Singapore: Which is Better?
The decision to invest in a property in Singapore can be both exciting and daunting, especially when faced with the...
Read More
Increase in ABSD April 2023
TLDR The impending rise in ABSD (Additional Buyer's Stamp Duty) is expected to suppress investment demand, allowing local homebuyers to...
Read More
Top 5 Best Urban Hiking Trails in Singapore
Singapore, known as the Garden City, is a bustling metropolis that offers a multitude of parks and nature reserves for...
Read More
6 Unexpected Property Warning Signs That Can Be Negative for Some, But Beneficial for Others
TLDR When considering property preferences, what may appear as a disadvantage to some buyers could be a unique opportunity for...
Read More
The 5 Most Popular Types of Properties to Buy in Singapore
The 5 Most Popular Types of Properties to Buy in Singapore 1. Condominiums: Condos are popular among buyers because they...
Read More
Top 5 Tourist Attractions in Singapore
Top 5 Tourist Attractions in Singapore Singapore, a vibrant city-state located in Southeast Asia, is known for its diverse culture,...
Read More
3 Winning Strategies for Skyrocketing Your Property Market Profits (Including Real-Life Success Stories)
TLDR In the dynamic property market of Singapore, maximizing profit is key for sellers and investors. Three essential strategies stand...
Read More
Top 5 : Singapore’s Most Desirable Properties: A Look at the City’s Most Coveted Real Estate
Singapore, a bustling city-state known for its impressive skyline and thriving economy, is home to some of the most desirable...
Read More
Case Study : With Income Of $180K per Annum, Which Options Should I Choose?
TLDR When making property decisions in Singapore, it's crucial to consider various factors like affordability, loan-to-value ratios, and CPF requirements....
Read More
Ouch! Our $1.8 Million Condo Investment Blunder: Unpacking 5 Crucial Takeaways from Our Bad Experience
TLDR The blog post delves into the complexities of real estate investments using Bob's experiences as examples. It highlights the...
Read More
Top 5 Benefits Of Singapore’s Cooling Measures For Home Buyers
Singapore's real estate market has experienced rapid growth in recent years, leading to concerns about affordability and sustainability. In response,...
Read More
Singapore’s Real Estate Market: Disproving 5 Common Misconceptions
Singapore's real estate market is a complex and dynamic market that can be difficult to navigate for new investors. With...
Read More
