5 Cons of Buying a New Development
Luxury properties in Districts 9 and 10 of Singapore are highly coveted, and for good reason. From stunning views and...
Read More
TLDR
A case study comparing condos near light industrial areas in Yishun and Bishan found that proximity to these zones does not negatively impact condo prices or profitability. In fact, condos closer to light industrial areas showed higher returns on investment (ROI) and better profitability over 10 years compared to those further away. Factors such as lower entry prices, good rental prospects from nearby workers, and market competition play a larger role in condo performance than industrial proximity. Heavy industries are usually far from residential zones, so light industrial areas near homes mostly consist of less disruptive uses like warehouses. Overall, industrial proximity is less significant than market positioning, entry price, and unit supply in determining condo value. For personalized real estate advice, consulting experts with data-driven insights is recommended.
Conventional wisdom in Singapore often dictates that proximity to industrial areas negatively impacts property values. However, this generalization oversimplifies the reality, as not all industrial areas are created equal. Heavy industries with significant pollution are typically located far from residential zones, while areas near homes tend to house lighter industries like warehouses and material suppliers. To examine the actual impact of these light industrial areas on condo prices, we conducted a case study in Yishun and Bishan.
Case Study: Yishun and Bishan
We selected Yishun and Bishan because they offer a sufficient number of condos both near and far from light industrial areas for a meaningful comparison. Executive Condominiums (ECs) were excluded to avoid distorting the data, as they are subsidized and have specific regulations.
Yishun Analysis:
In Yishun, condos near the industrial area include Yishun Emerald, Yishun Sapphire, Eight Courtyards, Symphony Suites, and Rafflesia Condominium. Condos further away include Canberra Residences, Lillydale, The Canopy, and The Nautical.
Comparing their price movements and Return on Investment (ROI) over a 10-year period (2014-2024), we found a surprising result: condos nearer the industrial area had a higher approximate ROI (around 41.91%) compared to those further away (around 21.76%).
Yishun Emerald and Yishun Sapphire, with their relatively low starting prices, showed strong performance. Canberra Residences and The Nautical, located further from the industrial area, seemed to underperform, while The Canopy and Bishan 8 performed well regardless of proximity.
Factors contributing to these trends include the influx of newer condos near Canberra Residences, creating stronger competition, and higher starting prices for Canberra Residences and The Nautical limiting their appreciation potential.
Analyzing profitability from 2011 onwards (to account for SSD), condos near industrial areas like Eight Courtyards and Symphony Suites had nearly all profitable transactions. Yishun Emerald and Yishun Sapphire also showed strong profitability despite some losing transactions.
This suggests that proximity to light industrial areas did not negatively impact profitability in Yishun. In fact, factors like entry prices and rental prospects, particularly the ready supply of tenants from nearby workers, appear to outweigh the influence of industrial proximity.
Bishan Analysis:
In Bishan, Tresalveo, Boonview, Marymount View, and Seasons View are near the industrial area, while Sky Habitat, Sky Vue, and Bishan 8 are further away.
Similar to Yishun, Bishan condos near industrial areas had a higher approximate ROI (55.33%) compared to those further away (32.91%). This again suggests no negative impact from industrial proximity.
Marymount View (near industrial) and Bishan 8 (further away) were top performers, indicating that industrial proximity may have less impact than other factors. Marymount View’s strong appreciation was likely influenced by its lower entry price.
Looking at profitability, Sky Habitat had the highest percentage of losing transactions, potentially due to its relaunch at a lower price point. However, condos closer to the industrial area, with the exception of Boonview (due to a small number of transactions), seemed to fare better.
Overall Conclusion:
Based on our case studies in Yishun and Bishan, proximity to light industrial areas does not appear to negatively impact condo profitability. In many cases, condos near these areas performed better, potentially due to factors like improved rentability and lower starting prices.
It is evident that other factors, such as market positioning, entry price, and the number of units, significantly outweigh industrial proximity as a primary determinant of condo performance. This may also be attributed to the nature of light industrial zones in Singapore, which are typically kept separate from residential areas to minimize pollution and noise.
For personalized advice on your property or guidance on your next purchase, consider consulting us who can provide data-driven insights tailored to your specific needs.
Should You Buy, Sell or Wait?
If you’re reading this, you must be trying to figure out the best course of action right now: is it the right time to buy or sell?
It’s difficult to give an exact answer since everyone’s situation is unique and what works for one person may not necessarily work for you.
I can bring you a wealth of on-the-ground experience and a data-driven approach to provide clarity and direction. From beginners to experienced investors, our top-down, objective approach will help you on your real estate journey.
I can help you by:
- Offering Strategic Real Estate Advice – I can help create a comprehensive plan to guide you through your property journey.
- Connecting Your Home with the Perfect Buyers – Through stunning visuals, an effective communication strategy, and an in-depth knowledge of the market, we’ll ensure your home is presented in the best possible way to fulfill your goals.
You May Also Like …
5 Reasons Why Condos Are The Best Real Estate Investment in Singapore
Investing in a condo in Singapore is a popular choice for both locals and foreigners. Condominiums offer a range of...
Read More
Is Housing Policy an Unintended Factor in Singapore’s Birth Rate?
TLDR Singapore’s housing policies contribute to its declining birth rate through a complex mix of factors beyond just price. Flat...
Read More
Don’t Get Scammed: The Top 5 Red Flags To Watch Out For In Singapore’s Property Market
Don't Get Scammed: The Top 5 Red Flags To Watch Out For In Singapore's Property Market When it comes to...
Read More
How to Maximise Your Home Value Before Selling : 6 Simple Steps
TLDR When looking to sell your home, consider simple ways to boost its value without costly renovations. Organize living spaces,...
Read More
5 Critical Mistakes to Avoid When Investing in Singapore Property: Insights and Advice from Experts
Investing in Singapore property can be a lucrative venture for investors, but it's important to avoid common mistakes that can...
Read More
The Top 10 Traits Of A Good Real Estate Agent
TLDR Jayson Ang, a reputable real estate agent in Singapore, offers extensive experience and a data-driven approach to guide clients...
Read More
Singapore Living: 5 Must-Know Factors for Choosing the Perfect Neighborhood
Singapore Living: 5 Must-Know Factors for Choosing the Perfect Neighborhood When it comes to purchasing a property in Singapore, the...
Read More
Downpayment For Condo: How Much Do First-Timers Need In Singapore?
TLDR The blog post delves into the complexities of condo downpayments in Singapore in light of the impact of Covid-19...
Read More
5 Hidden Expenses to Watch Out for When Buying a Home in Singapore
5 Hidden Expenses to Watch Out for When Buying a Home in Singapore Buying a property in Singapore can be...
Read More
Leasehold vs. Freehold Condos in Singapore: A Decade of Data
TLDR In Singapore’s property market (2014-2024), leasehold condos often outperform freehold in short-term holding (around 10 years) due to lower...
Read More
What is Buyer’s Stamp Duty (BSD) in Singapore and How Does It Work?
TLDR When it comes to navigating the Additional Buyers Stamp Duty (ABSD) in Singapore, legal strategies are available to overcome...
Read More
5 Reasons To Invest In UK Property In 2024 Instead Of Saving
TLDR Investing in UK property in 2024 offers significant advantages over saving due to the potential for long-term value growth,...
Read More
Top 5 Best Hidden Boutique Hotels in Singapore
Singapore, a vibrant city-state known for its iconic landmarks and diverse culture, offers a plethora of accommodation options for travelers....
Read More
Are Million-Dollar HDB Landed Homes Still Worth A Look In 2025 Despite Their Age?
TLDR Old HDB landed homes, like those in Whampoa, are rare and now fetch over $1.5 million, but their value...
Read More
What Happens To Your Housing Loan Once You Sell Your House?
TLDR When selling your home in Singapore, ensure you pay off your outstanding home loan, refund any CPF monies used,...
Read More
5 Key Insights to Take Away from the Latest 2022 Cooling Measures
TLDR Affordability of HDB Market: Government is focused on ensuring affordable public housing and may increase supply if needed. Long-term...
Read More
Neighbourhood Estate Guide: Is Holland Village the Most Charming and Relaxed of HDB Estates?
According to the 2014 master plan, Holland Village was given the prestigious title of an "identity node," confirming its status...
Read More
Top 5 Reasons : Why Developers Seem Hesitant To Commit To New Projects In Singapore
Singapore, a thriving global city-state, has long been known for its robust economy and attractive real estate market. However, in...
Read More
Rising Interest Rates : A Cause for Concern?
TLDR In 2021, the real estate market saw a surge in demand due to low interest rates and supply chain...
Read More
