Your search results

Avoid The Possibility Of Negative Cash Sales: Find Out How Much Your HDB Has To Appreciate To Steer Clear Of It!

Posted by Jayson Ang on January 31, 2023

| 0

TLDR

When selling your property, watch out for negative cash sales that could leave you with no money after CPF refunds. Consider factors like property appreciation, loan repayments, and market trends to avoid financial setbacks. Upgrading to a condo may require significant value appreciation in your HDB flat. Be cautious of bank loan challenges and fluctuating interest rates. To ensure a positive cash sale, strategize your CPF and cash allocations wisely. Keep an eye on market conditions and potential returns before making property decisions.

With resale flat prices reaching all-time highs, it is easy to assume that negative cash sales are a thing of the past. However, this isn’t always the case and negative cash sales still occur in a seller’s market. To avoid such a sale, you need to ensure that your flat has appreciated in value sufficiently.

What’s A Negative Cash Sale?

Having no cash on hand after refunding your CPF when you sell your property can be a major setback. For instance, if you sell your flat for $500,000, but need to give back $515,000 to your CPF account, you will find yourself with absolutely no money.

Even though you can still use your CPF for your next purchase, the banks ask for a minimum of five per cent of the cost to be paid in cash, so unless you are able to get that sum of money together, it can limit your future upgrade options.

Despite the fact that this scenario might not apply to everyone, the majority of people use their CPF to pay their mortgage so that they can save or invest their cash. Therefore, even if they face a negative cash sale situation, it doesn’t have to mean they are in a hopeless situation.

*As long as you sell at the market price, you don’t owe the additional $15,000; all you have to do is refund the full $500,000 into CPF.

Are You At Risk Of Experiencing A Negative Cash Sale If You Sell Right After MOP?

Let’s explore how much you would need to pay back to CPF for a $700,000 HDB resale flat, bought with a 25-year HDB loan and an initial $140,000 down payment plus a Buyer’s Stamp Duty of $15,600 – all of which are taken from CPF.

Assuming the flat is sold after 5 years and the loan is taken at the standard 2.6 per cent per annum with a maximum amount of 80 per cent, or $560,000, here’s what the refund would look like :

At the start of each year, we assume that the BSD and downpayment are made and the mortgage is paid through the same period. The interest accrued is then added to the total CPF amount used, resulting in a new balance which carries over to the following year. Mortgage payments are added to this sum and the accrued interest is added to the new balance, continuing this cycle.

Once you pass the 25th year, the amount of CPF refundable upon sale of your flat increases based solely on the interest that has accrued – given that your flat is already completely paid off.

Please be aware that the aforementioned example includes $2,500 of legal fees and 2% of the selling price as agent fees, both to be paid in cash.

How Much Must Your HDB Property Value Increase To Ensure You Don’t Have A Negative Cash Sale?

Let’s see how much your HDB needs to appreciate if you want to sell it in the fifth year after its MOP and not take a hit in the cash sale – and all this, without having to take into account any other factors than the ones in the table above.

Let’s run a simulation of HDB prices ranging from $300,000 to $1,000,000 and get the numbers!

The more expensive the HDB flat, the greater the potential appreciation in value – even if only incrementally.

From the chart, it’s clear that your flat needs to increase in value by 19% within a five-year span in order to avoid an adverse cash flow situation.

What If You Want To Use Some Of The Cash To Upgrade To A Condo?

For HDB upgraders, the typical price range they can afford is around $1.6 million. Therefore, you must have at least $80,000 in cash as a 5% down payment. To accomplish this, here’s an idea of how much your flat needs to appreciate for you to make the purchase:

In 5 years, the flat must increase in value from $700,000 to $916,230 – a 31% rise, which is not unheard of, but it also means that private property prices are going to be even higher than they are now.

Most Singaporeans don’t end up receiving the maximum loan amount available; the CPF allows up to $20,000 to be kept, any excess needs to go towards the purchase of property.

After subtracting the 2% selling fee, the remaining cash comprises the original price plus a legal fee of $2,500.

By 2023, Obtaining Bank Loans Has Become A Much More Challenging Endeavor

Not all are eligible for an HDB loan, and if you find yourself in the higher income bracket, HDB may suggest opting for a bank loan instead.

This could be an alarming risk for those looking for a cash sale, as the implications of such a decision are vast.

With bank loan rates continuously changing, the prospect of a sudden interest rate surge is disconcerting, especially considering that current interest rates are far higher than they were a decade ago.

Even opting for a fixed-rate loan could be risky as they are currently set at around four per cent.

Those who purchase a flat with a bank loan will need to see greater appreciation on their property than those with an HDB loan; in this example, the flat would need to appreciate to $904,513 with a 4% fixed rate loan taken out over five years, as well as a 25% downpayment.

With an interest rate 4% higher than 2.6%, the difference in cash after 5 years is almost $40K! Plus, opting for a down payment of $700K would have cost an additional 5%, or $35,000.

Buyers Of Resale Flats, Take Heed: Peak Prices Are Unlikely To Last

Purchasing a resale flat in 2023 could mean you are buying at a peak market rate, however, it is highly unlikely that these price increases can remain the same for the next five years.

This is due to the fact that HDB has increased their BTO flat production in 2022 and 2023, meaning a considerable amount of resale flats could be added to the market soon.

Therefore, if you were to sell your flat at this time, it is possible that you would not make the returns you were expecting and could end up with a negative cash sale.

Rather Than Pinning Your Hopes On A Rise In The Value Of Your Flat, The Most Sensible Approach Is To Conserve Your Cpf Funds

If you’re aiming to stay on top of your upgrading goals in 2023, your best move would be to use a mix of cash and CPF – that way, part of your loan can be paid off with cash, while the other part is covered by CPF.

But, if you’re looking to eliminate any risk, why not just use your CPF for the down payment and BSD and make your loan payments in cash – that way, you can guarantee a positive cash sale!

Looking to Sell Your Property?

Are you approaching the Minimum Occupation Period (MOP) of your HDB apartment or has the Seller Stamp Duty (SSD) window of your condo already passed?
It is always advantageous to have an understanding of the potential returns if you were to put your property up for sale. Additionally, you need to ascertain if your gains will enable you to upsize to the dream home in the neighbourhood you and your family have been longing for.
For an easy and reliable way to get a free Property Valuation, just send me a request!
If you’ve got a property-related story that you’d like to share, don’t hesitate to drop me a message and I’ll get back to you!
Alternatively, you can send me a DM and I’ll reach out to you

You May Also Like …

All Buying Tips Opinion

Bayshore: Reinventing the Experience of Living by the Beach

Jayson Ang – May 4, 2024 –

TLDR When deciding on buying or selling property in Bayshore, consider the recent developments and potential future growth. With a...

All Opinion

Why Aren’t Spacious, Wallet-Friendly Homes Our Reality Yet?

Jayson Ang – April 17, 2024 –

TLDR The article discusses the current housing market in Singapore, focusing on the challenges faced by individuals like Sherlyn Tan...

All Buying Tips Opinion

I Wouldn’t Rely Too Heavily On Discounts Related To ABSD This Year

Jayson Ang – February 28, 2025 –

TLDR The ABSD discount arises when developers approach their five-year deadline to sell 90% of units, facing a 40% penalty...

Mandarin Top 5

The Future Of Singapore Property Investing: 5 Trends To Watch Out For

Jayson Ang – July 10, 2024 –

The future of Singapore's property market is shaped by several emerging trends that reflect cautious optimism, enviable locations, and sociable...

All Buying Tips

When to Strike Gold: The Ultimate Guide to Selling Your House in Singapore!

Jayson Ang – June 28, 2024 –

TLDR When deciding the best time to sell your property, consider various factors such as market trends, financial goals, and...

All Selling Tips

Selling Your Home for the First Time in Singapore: A Step-by-Step Guide

Jayson Ang – March 10, 2026 –

TLDR Selling your home in Singapore involves careful planning over several stages. Start 4-6 weeks before listing by consulting a...

All Blog Posts Buying Tips

Avoid The Possibility Of Negative Cash Sales: Find Out How Much Your HDB Has To Appreciate To Steer Clear Of It!

Jayson Ang – January 31, 2023 –

TLDR When selling your property, watch out for negative cash sales that could leave you with no money after CPF...

Mandarin Top 5

The Top 5 Impact Of Singapore’s Ageing Population On The Property Market And Investment Opportunities

Jayson Ang – July 26, 2024 –

Singapore's ageing population is having a significant impact on the property market and investment opportunities. The top five effects include:...

All Buying Tips Opinion

Should You Splash Your Cash on a Condo Despite the Sky-High PSF?

Jayson Ang – December 2, 2023 –

TLDR The blog post discusses various aspects of investing in condos in Singapore, covering topics such as leasehold versus freehold...

Mandarin Top 5

5 Reasons Why It’s A Great Time To Buy Property In Singapore In 2024

Jayson Ang – February 24, 2024 –

Singapore's property market is known for its stability, high demand and strong returns. With a growing population, low unemployment rates,...

Mandarin Top 5

Top 5 Reasons Why Singapore’s Luxury Property Market Is Booming – Expert Analysis!

Jayson Ang – October 17, 2024 –

Singapore's luxury property market has been experiencing a significant boom in recent years, attracting the attention of investors and high-net-worth...

Mandarin Top 5

Top 5 Singapore Must-Dos: Unforgettable Experiences Await!

Jayson Ang – June 29, 2025 –

Singapore, a vibrant city-state known for its diverse culture and world-class attractions, offers an array of unforgettable experiences for both...

All Opinion

Snag a Sentosa Condo for 40% Off? Should You Consider It!

Jayson Ang – May 23, 2024 –

TLDR The Residences at W Singapore Sentosa Cove has slashed prices by over 40%, but there are important details to...

Buying Tips Mandarin Top 5

The 5 Most Common Mistakes First-Time Buyers Make (And How to Avoid Them)

Jayson Ang – June 12, 2023 –

The 5 Most Common Mistakes First-Time Buyers Make (And How to Avoid Them) Here are the 5 most common mistakes...

All Buying Tips Opinion

Are Early Bird Discounts At New Launches Genuine Or A Marketing Gimmick?

Jayson Ang – November 20, 2023 –

TLDR When considering investing in new property projects, understanding developers' pricing strategies is crucial. Early bird discounts are not just...

Mandarin Top 5

5 Tips : How To Spot A Good Investment Opportunity In Singapore’s Property Market

Jayson Ang – July 18, 2024 –

Singapore's property market offers a plethora of investment opportunities for both local and foreign investors. To spot a good investment...

All Buying Tips Opinion

Is It Better To Purchase A Larger HDB Or A Smaller Condo For $1 Million In 2025?

Jayson Ang – August 14, 2025 –

TLDR When comparing a large, centrally located resale flat (e.g., 5-room HDB) with a small condo around the $1 million...

Mandarin Top 5

Top 5 : Advantages of Owning a Luxury Condominium in Singapore for Long-Term Investment

Jayson Ang – February 23, 2025 –

Singapore, a thriving global city-state, has become an attractive destination for real estate investors. Among the various property types available,...