Neighbourhood Estate Guide: Is Holland Village the Most Charming and Relaxed of HDB Estates?
According to the 2014 master plan, Holland Village was given the prestigious title of an "identity node," confirming its status...
Read More
TLDR
Price Per Square Foot (PSF) is increasingly a poor measure of property value in Singapore due to regulatory changes that improved space efficiency, excluding non-livable areas from Gross Floor Area (GFA). Older properties with lower PSF may have inefficient layouts and higher renovation costs, making direct PSF comparisons misleading. PSF also ignores qualitative factors like unit quality, location, and unique features, and is less useful across different property types. Instead, total price (quantum) has a greater impact on buyers’ financial commitments and should be the primary focus. PSF might only be relevant when comparing very similar units. Buyers and sellers should prioritize a comprehensive, data-driven approach considering both quantum and qualitative factors rather than relying solely on PSF.
Price Per Square Foot (PSF) has long been a conventional method for comparing property prices, often mistakenly equated with value. The intuitive logic suggests that a lower PSF for two similarly sized properties implies better value. However, significant changes in Singapore’s property market have rendered this assumption often inaccurate, making PSF a potentially misleading indicator.
Why PSF is Becoming an Increasingly Poor Indicator
The relevance of PSF has diminished due to various regulatory changes over the years that have reshaped property layouts and efficiency. Historically, during the “bay window/planter era” of the 2010s, developers included spaces like air-con ledges, bay windows, and planters in the total square footage, for which buyers paid, despite these being non-chargeable to developers. This practice led to less efficient floor plans.
Subsequent regulations phased out these non-chargeable areas, leading to more efficient layouts. Most recently, the GFA (Gross Floor Area) harmonization rule has further streamlined designs by excluding unliveable spaces like air-con ledges and strata void spaces from the official GFA. Consequently, while the total price of a unit may remain the same, its reported PSF increases, creating a perception of higher prices when the actual livable space might be comparable.
For example, comparing three similar 3-bedroom properties in the East across different eras can yield a distorted picture if solely based on PSF:
As seen above, a seemingly lower PSF in older properties might not reflect real value differences, especially when considering potentially higher renovation costs and less efficient layouts. PSF also fails to account for inherent risks in older properties, such as impending en bloc sales or deteriorating facilities. This holds true for HDB properties as well.
Additional Reasons Why PSF Can Be Misleading:
- Lacks Qualitative Depth: A higher PSF might be justified by superior quality, better unit facing, proximity to premium amenities (e.g., sky gardens, elevated pools), or the exclusivity of a rare unit type (e.g., top-floor units with rooftop access, loft units). For instance, People’s Park Complex, despite its remarkably low PSF, might not be considered “better value” than a newer, more modern development like One Pearl Bank in its current condition. Dual-key units, which often have higher PSF due to their split layout, offer unique benefits like multi-generational living or rental income potential, which are not captured by a simple PSF metric.
- Ignores Space Efficiency: Efficient use of space is often more critical than sheer square footage, a factor PSF overlooks. A very large unit might boast a low PSF but could feature inefficient layouts with expansive hallways, disproportionately large balconies or patios (sometimes a third of the living room size, common in 80s terrace-style condos), or vast entry antechambers. These non-livable areas contribute to a higher reported square footage and lower PSF but translate to wasted space and higher maintenance.
- Ineffective for Comparing Different Property Types: PSF is most effective when comparing units of similar layouts within the same project. Its utility diminishes significantly when comparing across different property types. For example, bungalows at Sentosa Cove may have a low PSF compared to many condominiums due to their immense size, yet their overall quantum can still be in the double-digit millions. Conversely, compact city-fringe options like M condo might appear expensive by PSF (e.g., one-bedders exceeding $3,000 psf) but were among the few options offering units in the Beach Road/Bugis area for under $1 million at launch. Moreover, premium and penthouse units often command both larger sizes and higher PSFs.
Unless comparing highly similar units and layouts where PSF might serve as a “tie-breaker,” it’s not a versatile analytical tool.
The Primacy of Quantum:
Ultimately, the quantum (total price) of a property has the most direct impact on a buyer’s financial commitments, influencing the loan amount, stamp duties, and for investors, the rental yield and overall return. Focusing too much on PSF can be a distraction from this critical figure. During high-pressure sales situations, agents might emphasize PSF to sway buyers, so it’s important to keep the total quantum at the forefront of your decision-making.
Should You Buy, Sell or Wait?
If you’re reading this, you must be trying to figure out the best course of action right now: is it the right time to buy or sell?
It’s difficult to give an exact answer since everyone’s situation is unique and what works for one person may not necessarily work for you.
I can bring you a wealth of on-the-ground experience and a data-driven approach to provide clarity and direction. From beginners to experienced investors, our top-down, objective approach will help you on your real estate journey.
I can help you by:
- Offering Strategic Real Estate Advice – I can help create a comprehensive plan to guide you through your property journey.
- Connecting Your Home with the Perfect Buyers – Through stunning visuals, an effective communication strategy, and an in-depth knowledge of the market, we’ll ensure your home is presented in the best possible way to fulfill your goals.
You May Also Like …
Is it Better to Sell Your Newly Launched Condo Before or After Completion? Here’s What the Statistics Indicate
TLDR Determining the best time to sell a newly launched condo involves weighing the benefits of selling before or after...
Read More
Mega Developments vs. Regular Condos in Singapore: A Data-Driven Comparison
TLDR Mega-developments (1,000+ units) in Singapore, once seen as chaotic, now offer competitive pricing and extensive facilities, making them attractive...
Read More
Top 5 Questions to Ask : Is Singapore Property Investment for Me?
Singapore has long been a popular destination for property investors, both local and international. The city-state's stable economy, strong infrastructure,...
Read More
The Ultimate Checklist for Work-From-Home Homebuyers in Singapore: Beyond the Basics
TLDR Remote work has changed what makes an ideal home—buyers now need to prioritize productivity and well-being alongside location and...
Read More
Top 5 Tips : How Does One Choose Good Property In Singapore?
Singapore, a thriving city-state known for its impressive skyline and robust economy, has always been an attractive destination for property...
Read More
The Impact of a Real Estate Agent on Your Property’s Selling Price
TLDR In the world of real estate, the value of property agents lies in their ability to create competition among...
Read More
Top 5 Mistakes to Avoid When Buying Property in Singapore – Expert Insights!
Purchasing a property in Singapore can be an exciting and rewarding experience, especially for those looking to invest in the...
Read More
Uncover the Secrets of Buying Older Properties – What They Won’t Tell You!
TLDR When considering the appeal of older properties in hipster neighborhoods in Singapore, it's crucial to understand the benefits and...
Read More
5 Reasons : Why Investing In Singapore Property Is The Best Decision I Ever Made
Investing in property is a great way to build wealth and secure a stable source of passive income. When it...
Read More
Top 5 Places to Learn About Singapore’s Diversity
Singapore, a vibrant city-state in Southeast Asia, is well-known for its diverse culture and rich history. A melting pot of...
Read More
Avoid The Possibility Of Negative Cash Sales: Find Out How Much Your HDB Has To Appreciate To Steer Clear Of It!
TLDR When selling your property, watch out for negative cash sales that could leave you with no money after CPF...
Read More
Top 5 Singapore Must-Dos: Unforgettable Experiences Await!
Singapore, a vibrant city-state known for its diverse culture and world-class attractions, offers an array of unforgettable experiences for both...
Read More
5 Biggest Mistakes I Made When Starting Out In Singapore Property Investing
Investing in Singapore property can be an excellent way to generate passive income and build long-term wealth. However, like any...
Read More
Top 5 : Greatest Challenges That Investors Face In Singapore’s Real Estate Market
Singapore's real estate market is a dynamic and attractive investment landscape for both local and international investors. Known for its...
Read More
Why Can’t Everyone Have Homes In Good Locations?
TLDR In a nutshell, the Singapore property market is undergoing significant changes, with the introduction of a new housing classification...
Read More
When Is The Best Time To Buy A New Launch?
TLDR When it comes to new property launches, timing is crucial. Early buyers often secure the best prices due to...
Read More
Top 5 : Places to See Singapore’s Skyline at Night
Singapore, a bustling metropolis known for its stunning skyline, offers an array of vantage points to witness the city's architectural...
Read More
Find Your Dream Home: Top 5 Property Investments for Families in Singapore
As one of the most prosperous countries in the world, Singapore is an attractive destination for families looking to invest...
Read More
Singapore Property Price Set to Explode Upwards in 2024?
TLDR Understanding the factors influencing property prices in Singapore for 2024 can help in making informed decisions. Despite high rental...
Read More
