TLDR
Over the past decade, 2+Study units (compact 3-bedroom layouts) consistently outperformed standard 2-bedroom units in resale gains across most projects, both for long-term and short-term holdings. Examples include Stirling Residences and Parc Esta, where 2+Study units recorded significantly higher profit margins. Rental yields, however, tend to be slightly higher for regular 2-bedroom units due to their lower price points, though the difference is marginal. The 2+Study option offers a qualitative advantage in rentability, appealing to a wider tenant base such as small families, roommates, and remote workers needing extra space. Buyers should carefully assess the functionality of the “study” space and kitchen design before purchasing. Overall, for those seeking capital appreciation, 2+Study units present better returns, while rental yield advantages remain modest. Demand for these units is expected to grow as affordability for larger units declines.
With current high property prices making 3-bedroom and larger units less accessible, 2-bedroom units, particularly the more spacious 2+Study (often marketed as “compact 3-bedders”), have garnered significant attention. A key question for buyers and investors is whether the additional “study” space translates into better returns or simply eats into rental yield. This analysis examines the gains and rental performance of these two unit types over the past decade.
Resale Gains: 2-Bedroom vs. 2+Study (2014-2024)
An analysis of 11 projects that feature both 2-bedroom and 2+Study configurations, based on new-to-resale transactions from 2014 to 2024, reveals a clear trend:
- Overall Trend: In 8 out of 11 projects, 2+Study units demonstrated higher average gains compared to regular 2-bedroom units.
- Significant Differences:
- At Stirling Residences, 2+Study units saw average gains of $476,290 (36%), significantly outperforming 2-bedroom units which gained $268,719 (22%), a difference of over $207,000.
- Parc Esta exhibited similar results, with 2+Study units gaining $476,266 (35%) versus $323,711 (27%) for standard 2-bedroom layouts.
- Exceptions: Amber Park and Mont Botanik Residence were among the few projects where standard 2-bedroom units slightly outperformed 2+Study.
Interestingly, Martin Modern’s unprofitable transactions included six 2-bedroom units and only one 2+Study unit, suggesting potentially better downside protection for the latter, though this is based on limited data.
New-to-Subsale Performance (Before TOP):
Analyzing new-to-subsale transactions (properties sold by an initial buyer to another party before the condo is fully built), a similar pattern emerges:
- Consistent Outperformance: In 12 out of 16 projects, 2+Study units recorded higher average gains than regular 2-bedroom units.
- Notable Gaps:
- Martin Modern saw 2+Study units gaining $239,094 (12%) compared to $135,969 (7%) for 2-bedroom units.
- At Parc Esta, 2+Study units gained $357,750 (26%) versus $264,129 (23%) for 2-bedroom units.
- Outliers: Kent Ridge Hill Residences and Sky Everton were exceptions where 2-bedroom units yielded better gains.
This data suggests that even for shorter holding periods, the 2+Study layout tends to deliver superior resale outcomes. A notable anecdote from Sky Everton, despite its limited sample size, showed a 2+Study unit incurring a significantly smaller loss ($26,000) compared to a 2-bedroom unit ($132,000), although holding period differences might have influenced this.
Rental Rates and Yields: Landlord’s Perspective
Analyzing rental data to precisely compare 2-bedroom and 2+Study units is challenging due to URA’s broad size ranges. However, by matching unit sizes from sale transactions to corresponding URA rental size bands for 2024, an estimated rental yield comparison can be made:
The data indicates that 2+Study units generally do not offer a significant rental yield advantage. In most cases, standard 2-bedroom units slightly edge out 2+Study units in yield due to their lower price points. For example, Whistler Grand’s 2-bedroom units yielded 3.97% compared to 3.64% for 2+Study units, primarily due to the latter’s higher average purchase price. While the differences are often marginal, the slightly lower yield for 2+Study units is consistent across most projects.
Rentability: A Qualitative Advantage of 2+Study:
Despite similar or slightly lower yields, the qualitative advantage of a 2+Study unit lies in its enhanced rentability. Its versatility allows it to cater to a broader tenant demographic, including:
- Small families
- Roommates
- Single tenants requiring a dedicated home office or additional storage, particularly relevant in a post-pandemic era with increased hybrid work arrangements.
This broader appeal can make it easier for landlords to find and retain tenants, potentially reducing vacancy periods. For landlords willing to stretch their budget, the increased versatility of a 2+Study unit might justify the investment.
Conclusion:
The analysis largely favors 2+Study units in terms of resale gains, both for long-term holding and shorter subsale periods. As the affordability of larger units becomes more challenging, the demand for 2+Study units, bridging the gap between compact 2-bedders and larger 3-bedders, is likely to persist or grow.
However, not all 2+Study units are created equal. Prospective buyers should carefully evaluate:
- Post-Harmonization Status: Whether the project is pre- or post-harmonization, as older designs might include wasted space (e.g., large planter boxes, oversized air-con ledges).
- Functionality of “+1” Space: Ensure the “study” is a genuinely functional, enclosable room with proper ventilation and natural light, not just an awkward corner.
- Kitchen Design: For families, the kitchen space is crucial. Look for functional layouts like nook kitchens with ample cabinetry and countertops.
Should You Buy, Sell or Wait?
If you’re reading this, you must be trying to figure out the best course of action right now: is it the right time to buy or sell?
It’s difficult to give an exact answer since everyone’s situation is unique and what works for one person may not necessarily work for you.
I can bring you a wealth of on-the-ground experience and a data-driven approach to provide clarity and direction. From beginners to experienced investors, our top-down, objective approach will help you on your real estate journey.
I can help you by:
- Offering Strategic Real Estate Advice – I can help create a comprehensive plan to guide you through your property journey.
- Connecting Your Home with the Perfect Buyers – Through stunning visuals, an effective communication strategy, and an in-depth knowledge of the market, we’ll ensure your home is presented in the best possible way to fulfill your goals.
You May Also Like …
Jayson Ang – March 22, 2024 – Share
Retirees have unique needs when it comes to property investments. They require properties that offer comfort, security, and easy access...
Read More
Jayson Ang – March 5, 2023 – Share
TLDR The Singapore property market faces challenges with the ongoing en bloc stalemate. Lower success rates, higher development risks, and...
Read More
Jayson Ang – October 3, 2024 – Share
TLDR Over the past two decades in Singapore, the trend of HDB residents upgrading to landed properties has fluctuated. While...
Read More
Jayson Ang – January 3, 2023 – Share
TLDR Understanding the complexities of upgrading from an HDB flat to a private property in Singapore involves selling your HDB...
Read More
Jayson Ang – December 7, 2022 – Share
When you flip open the papers or turn on the news nowadays, the common buzzwords are "INFLATION", " INTEREST RATE...
Read More
Jayson Ang – December 7, 2024 – Share
Singapore, a vibrant city-state known for its diverse culture and stunning skyline, is also home to some of the most...
Read More
Jayson Ang – March 30, 2024 – Share
Singapore, a bustling city-state known for its iconic skyline and innovative architecture, is home to some of the most stunning...
Read More
Jayson Ang – September 4, 2024 – Share
The real estate market is a complex and ever-changing landscape, with various factors influencing the value of a property. When...
Read More
Jayson Ang – September 6, 2024 – Share
Investing in real estate is an exciting and potentially lucrative venture. In Singapore, a thriving property market attracts both local...
Read More
Jayson Ang – January 16, 2025 – Share
Investing in a luxury condominium in Singapore is an attractive option for investors looking to diversify their portfolio and enjoy...
Read More
Jayson Ang – July 17, 2025 – Share
TLDR Shorter lease HDB flats are typically about 22–25% cheaper than their 99-year counterparts, based on both resale and BTO...
Read More
Jayson Ang – December 29, 2022 – Share
TLDR Decoupling in Singapore's real estate refers to the process of separating property ownership to avoid Additional Buyer's Stamp Duty...
Read More
Jayson Ang – January 28, 2023 – Share
TLDR When it comes to real estate investments in Singapore amidst rising inflation rates, consider strategies such as capitalizing on...
Read More
Jayson Ang – March 29, 2024 – Share
Investing in property is a popular option in Singapore, with many investors seeing it as a lucrative way to build...
Read More
Jayson Ang – June 22, 2024 – Share
Investing in Singapore's property market can be a good retirement plan for several reasons. Here are five key factors that...
Read More
Jayson Ang – November 19, 2024 – Share
TLDR Navigating the Additional Buyers Stamp Duty (ABSD) in Singapore can be daunting for property investors. To save on ABSD...
Read More
Jayson Ang – March 14, 2025 – Share
TLDR Determining the best time to sell a newly launched condo involves weighing the benefits of selling before or after...
Read More
Jayson Ang – March 7, 2024 – Share
Luxury properties in Districts 9 and 10 of Singapore are highly coveted, and for good reason. From stunning views and...
Read More
Jayson Ang – April 11, 2025 – Share
Singapore's real estate market has experienced rapid growth in recent years, leading to concerns about affordability and sustainability. In response,...
Read More
Jayson Ang – February 24, 2024 – Share
Singapore, a melting pot of diverse cultures and rich culinary heritage, is home to some of the most delectable local...
Read More
