Singapore Private Residential Market Outlook 2023
TLDR The Singapore residential property market has shown resilience in 2022, with price growth in both private housing and HDB...
Read More
The Singaporean government possesses considerable authority to reclaim land, whether freehold or not, in accordance with the Land Acquisition Act. Thankfully, this authority has been exercised infrequently since the 1960s, a period during which it was essential for constructing mass housing and restructuring the city. However, this does not imply that it has been entirely unused; in fact, some private property owners have been taken aback by its application even in more recent times. Here’s an overview:
What is the Land Acquisition Act?
This legislation permits the government to reclaim privately owned land for developments that serve the public interest. Although its usage has been limited in recent years, there was a time between 1959 and 1984 when the act facilitated the recovery of approximately 177 square kilometers of land, which represented roughly one-third of Singapore at that period.
There are only three straightforward criteria:
5 (1) Whenever any particular land is needed –
- For any public purpose
- by any person, corporation or statutory board, for any work or an undertaking which, in the opinion of the Minister, is of public benefit or of public utility or in the public interest; or
- for any residential, commercial or industrial purposes
This topic is not without its debates. You will encounter individuals who will passionately express their views on the acquisition of residential land for the purpose of selling it to private developers, questioning whether this action truly serves the “public utility” or is genuinely “in the public interest.”
(However, that is merely their perspective, and the government is legally permitted to proceed with such actions.)
Is the government truly capable of “reclaiming land at a low cost”?
This is a prevalent concern among landowners. What if your property is seized, leading to significant losses due to inadequate compensation? Let’s explore the origins of these anxieties:
Historically, compensation for land appropriated by the government did not reflect its value at the time of acquisition. For instance, in 1987, the compensation rates for land were based on their values from 1973. For properties acquired between 1987 and 1993, the values were aligned with those from 1986, and so on. This often resulted in financial losses since land values typically appreciate over time, which likely contributed to the longstanding grievances about how the government “acquires land at low prices.”
However, improvements have been implemented. On February 12, 2007, the legislation was revised to ensure that current values (i.e., those at the actual time of acquisition) are taken into account. Consequently, property owners since that date have benefited from much fairer compensation if their land is expropriated, in contrast to the experiences of previous generations.
Recent instances of land acquisition and the associated challenges include:
- The Chuan Park Car Park Case
- The church parking lot controversy
- Residences displaced due to the Thomson-East Coast Line requirements
- The case involving properties at 68 to 74 Thomson Road
- Utilizing the area beneath your condominium
1. The Chuan Park Car Park Case
In June 2003, Chuan Park, a leasehold condominium completed in 1985, lost 220 square meters of land to accommodate the Circle Line. This area included approximately 17 parking spaces, and residents were quite frustrated when they learned that the compensation amount was just $1.
However, it was contended that this land acquisition would bring the Lorong Chuan MRT station much closer to Chuan Park, and that the anticipated increase in property values from the loss of those 17 parking lots made the decision relatively equitable.
While this reasoning may seem logical on paper, there are still ongoing debates about it today. Such situations can lead to misunderstandings, which often contribute to the spread of rumors regarding the government “taking properties” for little cost.
2. The Parking Lot Controversy
This is referenced in the same link above. In this case, a church lost part of its parking lot for just $1. The reason for this was a planning error that designated the area as a “road.”
(If the area is classified as a road, it’s not surprising that the owner received only $1, since the land cannot be utilized for anything else.)
Ultimately, it was a case of mislabeling, and the government later offered $64,000 in compensation once the situation was clarified. However, before this resolution, rumors circulated again about the government acquiring land for just $1.
(The residents of Chuan Park, who received $1 for their 17 parking spaces, likely had their own opinions on the matter!)
3. Residences displaced due to the Thomson-East Coast Line requirements
In 2016, the Thomson-East Coast Line (TEL) construction led to the acquisition of 15 properties in the Katong Area. This included six semi-detached homes and nine walk-up apartments, amounting to a total compensation of $45 million.
This resulted in an average compensation of approximately $1,270 per square foot. Some homeowners contested this amount, with one individual asserting that a fair valuation would range from $1,300 to $1,600 per square foot. Out of curiosity, we looked into this claim and found it to be incorrect.
Source: Square Foot Research
The average for 2016 was $1,189 to $1,273 psf for 2016, which last appreciated to $1,636 psf in May this year. So it was actually an average deal for the residents after you tack on the inconveniences of having to move.
4. The case involving properties at 68 to 74 Thomson Road
This building, which was freehold, was finished in 1964. Engineers determined that it was too hazardous to keep occupied because earthworks for the North South Corridor (NSC) posed a threat to its structural stability.
Details regarding compensation for this case remain unclear, though some owners felt they received inadequate compensation. Nevertheless, this incident served as a crucial reminder that owning a freehold property does not guarantee protection against land acquisition. It raises concerns about the risks associated with owning a highly central property—such as a freehold in a major neighborhood hub—especially when new road and rail connections are planned.
Additionally, many people might not anticipate that land acquisition would replace what is likely a more lucrative en-bloc sale.
5. Utilizing the area beneath your condominium
In 2015, the State Lands Act underwent amendments, granting you ownership of the land beneath your home up to a depth of 30 meters; anything beyond that depth falls under government jurisdiction. The amendment also enables the government to assert claims over airspace and subterranean space without needing to first claim the surface land, although this largely doesn’t impact homeowners directly.
So, what has sparked this newfound interest in claiming the land beneath residential properties? The answer seems to lie in the concept of underground cities. Rather than solely expanding upward, Singapore may look to develop downwards as well, concealing roads and other infrastructure below ground level. This approach could potentially alleviate our traffic issues by relocating roads underground, freeing the surface primarily for pedestrian use.
As of now, the implications of these changes remain to be seen, and it will likely be some time before they materialize. When the time comes, it will be interesting to observe how Singaporeans respond to the prospect of highways, train lines, and other constructions being built beneath their homes.
Should You Buy, Sell or Wait?
If you’re reading this, you must be trying to figure out the best course of action right now: is it the right time to buy or sell?
It’s difficult to give an exact answer since everyone’s situation is unique and what works for one person may not necessarily work for you.
I can bring you a wealth of on-the-ground experience and a data-driven approach to provide clarity and direction. From beginners to experienced investors, our top-down, objective approach will help you on your real estate journey.
I can help you by:
- Offering Strategic Real Estate Advice – I can help create a comprehensive plan to guide you through your property journey.
- Connecting Your Home with the Perfect Buyers – Through stunning visuals, an effective communication strategy, and an in-depth knowledge of the market, we’ll ensure your home is presented in the best possible way to fulfill your goals.
You May Also Like …
Top 5 : Best Street Art Murals in Singapore
Singapore, a vibrant and multicultural city-state, is not only known for its iconic landmarks and delicious cuisine but also for...
Read More
5 Proven Strategies for Increasing the Value of Your Singapore Property
In Singapore's competitive real estate market, adding value to your property can be the key to making a profitable investment....
Read More
Unpacking Property Ownership: Joint Tenancy vs. Tenancy-in-Common
TLDR When a property has multiple owners, the choice of ownership type is crucial to determine how shares are distributed...
Read More
Lessons from the Rollercoaster Ride: Homebuyers Share Their Singapore Housing Market Experiences
TLDR The Singapore housing market is a rollercoaster of unpredictable changes. Three homebuyers share their experiences: Tristan waited too long...
Read More
Is the Singapore Property Market Set for a Dip in 2024?
TLDR The Singapore property market is experiencing shifts with Morgan Stanley adjusting its outlook on major developers. A forecast predicts...
Read More
6 Compelling Reasons Why 3-Bedroom Condos Might Shrink Further
TLDR Three-bedroom units in Singapore have significantly downsized from 1,700-1,800 sq. ft. in the 1980s to around 1,000 sq. ft....
Read More
Could You Still End Up Losing Money When Buying Property in Singapore During a Market Slump?
TLDR When it comes to property investments, timing is crucial. Buying at the right moment is only half the battle;...
Read More
Planning for Retirement: Considerations for Downsizing Your Property
TLDR Downsizing your home for retirement can bring financial security, closer family ties, and new adventures. Consider the benefits of...
Read More
The Quick Guide For Buying Landed Property In Singapore
TLDR When it comes to purchasing a landed property in Singapore, there are three main types to consider: terrace houses,...
Read More
Top 5 : Tips To Plan Your Retirement in Property Investments in Singapore
Planning for retirement is a crucial aspect of financial management, and property investment has emerged as a popular strategy for...
Read More
Top 5 Seafood Restaurants in Singapore
Singapore, a melting pot of cultures and culinary delights, is well-known for its diverse food scene. With its strategic location...
Read More
Are You Ready to Take on the Singapore Property Market in 2023? 12 Reasons to Be Hopeful (Or Wary)!
2022 sure was a rollercoaster ride for the property market, and the world! From war in Europe to skyrocketing interest...
Read More
5 Things to Know About the Singapore Property Tax System
5 Things to Know About the Singapore Property Tax System Here are 5 things you need to know about the...
Read More
Top 5 Tips : Spot These Warning Signs Before Making a Home Purchase!
Purchasing a home is one of the most significant financial decisions you will make in your lifetime. It's essential to...
Read More
What If Sellers Back Out of a Deal?
TLDR When a seller unexpectedly withdraws from a property transaction before a contract is signed, they are legally allowed to...
Read More
Is Singapore’s Property Market on the Verge of a Crash? Understanding the 5 Factors at Play
The Singapore property market has long been an attractive option for both local and international investors. However, as with any...
Read More
Ouch! Our $1.8 Million Condo Investment Blunder: Unpacking 5 Crucial Takeaways from Our Bad Experience
TLDR The blog post delves into the complexities of real estate investments using Bob's experiences as examples. It highlights the...
Read More
What Is The Best Location To Purchase A House To Ensure Your Child Has The Highest Probability Of Attending A Well-Renowned Primary School?
TLDR Parents often seek homes within 1km of desired primary schools to increase enrollment chances. Consider oversubscription rates and population...
Read More
Larger Living Spaces: The New Demand Surge Post-Pandemic
TLDR We explore the significant impact of digital marketing strategies on business growth in today's competitive landscape. It highlights the...
Read More
