3 Things You Need to Know if You Are Buying a Second Property
TLDR When considering buying a second property in Singapore, ensure eligibility by meeting the Minimum Occupancy Period (MOP) and understanding...
Read More
TLDR
The 99-to-1 property ownership split in Singapore, where one spouse holds 99% and the other 1%, is used to reduce Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty (ABSD) when buying multiple properties. However, a recent High Court case (Hillcrest Arcadia) revealed that beneficial ownership depends on actual financial contributions, not just title shares. The court indicated that intending to use this split to avoid ABSD could be unlawful, even if not penalized when the plan is unexecuted. The Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (IRAS) may audit and impose heavy penalties if tax avoidance is detected, with no time limit on such audits. Despite this, many buyers are misled about the risks by agents or lawyers. Buyers should seek clear advice and understand the risks before using this strategy, especially as penalties have become more severe with rising property prices. Personalized, data-driven real estate guidance is recommended for making informed buy, sell, or wait decisions.
The 99-to-1 property ownership split, a strategy commonly used in Singapore for over a decade, involves one co-owner (typically a spouse) holding 99% of a property, while the other holds 1%. The underlying intention is that when funds become available for each to own a separate property, the 1% share is transferred to the other spouse. This theoretically incurs Buyer’s Stamp Duty (BSD) only on the 1% portion, allowing the spouse who now has a “zero” property count to purchase a second property without incurring Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty (ABSD). This has long been a cornerstone of the “sell one, buy two” strategy. However, a recent High Court case has cast light on the legality of this practice.
The Hillcrest Arcadia Case:
In a notable case, a couple purchased a Hillcrest Arcadia condo with a 99:1 ownership split. The female spouse claimed 99% ownership, as stated on the title. The relationship, however, dissolved less than a year later. When the couple split, she asserted full ownership of her 99% share.
However, the High Court intervened. The judge ruled that based on the boyfriend’s financial contributions, he effectively owned 54% of the property. This decision undermined her 99% claim, emphasizing that financial contributions, not just paper titles, determine beneficial ownership.
More significantly, the case revealed a crucial detail: “The pair admitted that they planned for Mr Ngor to transfer and pay taxes on his one per cent share to Ms Wong when they decide to buy a second property. Justice Lee said there was no nefarious intention or knowledge that this would be an unlawful act. Moreover, the plan was never carried out.”
The phrase “would be an unlawful act” is key. It suggests that while the Court did not penalize them (as the plan was unexecuted), it implicitly deemed the intention to circumvent ABSD through this method as problematic.
Official Stance on 99-to-1 Splits:
A parliamentary response further clarifies the official stance: “Whether a ‘99-to-1’ arrangement involves tax avoidance depends on the facts and circumstances surrounding the specific case. Should IRAS determine that tax avoidance has occurred, it will recover the rightful amount of stamp duty from the buyers, and may impose a 50 per cent surcharge on the additional stamp duty payable. There is no statutory time limit for stamp duty audits.”
This indicates that while a 99-to-1 tenancy-in-common split is not inherently illegal, its contrived use specifically for tax avoidance can be challenged by authorities.
Lack of Clear Communication to Buyers:
Despite this nuanced reality, many buyers report being assured by property agents or lawyers that the 99-to-1 strategy carries no risks. This often leads to buyers unknowingly entering a legal “grey area,” only to face audit letters and potential penalties later.
There is a pressing need for more transparent communication regarding the risks associated with such strategies. If a 99-to-1 split is recommended, all potential risks, not just the perceived benefits, should be clearly articulated to buyers. In 2025, with higher property prices, the penalties for tax avoidance could be substantial, making it even more critical for buyers to be fully informed.
Should You Buy, Sell or Wait?
If you’re reading this, you must be trying to figure out the best course of action right now: is it the right time to buy or sell?
It’s difficult to give an exact answer since everyone’s situation is unique and what works for one person may not necessarily work for you.
I can bring you a wealth of on-the-ground experience and a data-driven approach to provide clarity and direction. From beginners to experienced investors, our top-down, objective approach will help you on your real estate journey.
I can help you by:
- Offering Strategic Real Estate Advice – I can help create a comprehensive plan to guide you through your property journey.
- Connecting Your Home with the Perfect Buyers – Through stunning visuals, an effective communication strategy, and an in-depth knowledge of the market, we’ll ensure your home is presented in the best possible way to fulfill your goals.
You May Also Like …
Top 5 Must-Know Facts about Luxury Properties in Districts 9 of Singapore
Singapore, a bustling city-state known for its impressive skyline and vibrant economy, has always been an attractive destination for property...
Read More
Top 5 : Most Profitable Neighborhoods To Invest In For Singapore Property Investment 2025
As the global economy continues to recover, the real estate market in Singapore remains a promising investment opportunity for savvy...
Read More
The Significance of Choosing the Right Condo: A Real-Life Tale of Two $1.8 Million Investments with Significantly Different Results.
TLDR When contemplating property investments in Singapore, consider various factors like rental performance, unit count, access to train lines, and...
Read More
Retiring in Singapore? Here’s Where to Find the 5 Best Property Investments for Comfort and Security!
Retirees have unique needs when it comes to property investments. They require properties that offer comfort, security, and easy access...
Read More
The Integrated Living Experience: Benefits and Drawbacks of Condos Above an MRT
TLDR Integrated developments in Singapore combine residential units with commercial spaces and direct MRT access, offering convenience and car-free living....
Read More
6 Myths About Using Your CPF For Housing
TLDR When it comes to purchasing a house in Singapore using CPF funds, there are several myths that need to...
Read More
Top 5 Tips : How to Choose the Right Type of Property to Invest in Singapore – Expert Tips and Analysis!
Investing in property has long been a popular method for growing wealth in Singapore. With million-dollar HDBs being sold and...
Read More
Why Home Staging Is Important In A Competitive Real Estate Market
Singapore's property scene has always been a powerhouse, effortlessly combining the new with the old. It's a real estate playground...
Read More
Top 5 Singaporean Dishes to Try
Singapore, a melting pot of diverse cultures and flavors, is known for its rich culinary heritage. With influences from Chinese,...
Read More
Discover the Best Breakfast in Singapore: Top 5 Must-Try Spots!
Trying out some of the best breakfast places, I've put together a list of the top 5 must-try breakfast spots...
Read More
Singapore Luxury Property: 5 Reasons to Add it to Your Trophy Collection
Singapore Luxury Property: 5 Reasons to Add it to Your Trophy Collection When it comes to luxury property investments, Singapore...
Read More
Singapore Property Bubble Ahead? My Friends Share My Market Predictions
TLDR The author delves into various opinions on the Singapore property market for the year 2023. Experts have differing views...
Read More
The Top 5 Reasons To Invest In Singapore Property
Singapore, a small island nation with a thriving economy, has long been considered an attractive destination for property investment. The...
Read More
Can You Skip the 15-Month Wait When Selling Private and Buying Resale HDB?
TLDR The 15-month wait-out rule requires private homeowners to sell their property and wait 15 months before buying a resale...
Read More
5 Pros of Buying a New Development
Deciding whether to buy a new development or a resale property can be a challenge. In the next few video...
Read More
Top 5 Cafes in Singapore for Brunch
Singapore, a melting pot of cultures and flavors, offers an incredible array of culinary experiences to tantalize your taste buds....
Read More
Top 5 Tips for First-Time Chinese Buyers Looking to Invest in Singapore Today
Top 5 Tips for First-Time Chinese Buyers Looking to Invest in Singapore Today Here are the top 5 tips for...
Read More
Debunked! 6 Popular Property Myths of 2023, Including the 99-1 Loophole – Legal or Not?
TLDR This blog post delves into various aspects of the Singapore property market, including topics such as decoupling, 99-1 property...
Read More
Market Mistakes in Property Investment: Key Lessons and Strategies for Success
TLDR In property investment, common mistakes include lack of research, overleveraging, and neglecting due diligence. To succeed, conduct thorough market...
Read More
